Defense witnesses deepen questions over VP Duterte’s wealth and interests

0
26

By Francessca S. Abalos

DEFENSE WITNESSES in Vice-President (VP) Sara Duterte-Carpio’s impeachment trial reinforced allegations of unexplained wealth instead of rebutting them, while raising questions about her financial disclosures and business interests, analysts said.

“Some of the [defense witness’] testimonies appear to have reinforced rather than weakened the prosecution’s allegations, particularly concerning the Vice-President’s business interests and financial transactions,” Ederson DT. Tapia, a political science professor at the University of Makati, told BusinessWorld via Facebook Messenger.

Ms. Duterte’s defense team presented six witnesses from Nov. 9 to 12 to explain specific transactions and financial records and counter allegations of P817.87 million in unexplained wealth.

However, Edmund S. Tayao, president and chief executive officer of Political Elemental Researchers and Strategists, said the testimonies raised further questions about matters for which Ms. Duterte could be held accountable.

Suzette B. Balucanag-Punay, corporate counsel for GenCorp Industries, Inc. and Metro City Chow Foods Corp., testified that Ms. Duterte had no affiliation with GenCorp but received about P2.14 million from a “loose investment” in one of its Jollibee branches.

Ms. Balucanag-Punay could not provide documents explaining the payments when senator-judges asked her about the investment, Mr. Tayao said.

“A defense witness is supposed to clarify or challenge the evidence against the respondent, not introduce further questions that the defense itself must now explain,” Mr. Tapia said.

Both analysts said the defense focused on peripheral issues instead of directly addressing the more serious allegations.

The defense also challenged two credit card purchases by Ms. Duterte’s husband, Manases R. Carpio, worth a combined P456,889. Witnesses classified the purchases as personal expenses.

Mr. Tayao said the issue was not the purpose of the purchases but the propriety of spending such a large amount, which remained unexplained.

The Duterte family’s strategy was to generate publicity without directly addressing the allegations, he said.

“They make an announcement, they talk about it a lot,” he said. “And because of so much promotion, everyone’s appetite is whetted, so you wait for it and expect that something actually happens out of it, and then suddenly, nothing actually is settled.”

Mr. Tapia said Ms. Duterte was best placed to explain her assets, bank records and business interests. Although cross-examination posed a risk, avoiding the central allegations would be more damaging, he said.

Mr. Tayao said Ms. Duterte’s failure to explain her statements of assets, liabilities and net worth during earlier House of Representatives inquiries contributed to the grounds for impeachment.

Her testimony might not resolve the questions, he said.

“[If] she has real explanations, then she should appear by all means,” he said. “But if the truth is that she actually doesn’t have any explanation whatsoever as to whether all of these accusations were actually committed… it won’t help that she will appear.”

Ms. Duterte’s defense team did not immediately respond to a Viber message seeking comment.